Do You Need New Car Replacement Insurance?

Do You Need New Car Replacement Insurance?

Written by Caitlin Wood
Last Updated December 9, 2021

Responsible drivers do what they can to stay safe on the roads and make sure that their vehicles are protected against any incidents that would require a lot more than just a touch up to repair. In unfortunate cases, cars involved in accidents are totalled and are no longer deemed fit to be driven. 

Having a new car replacement policy can help compensate you just enough to replace your totalled vehicle with one of similar make and model, rather than just getting reimbursed for the actual cash value of your car.

Let’s go into more detail about what new car replacement insurance is and if it’s worth paying a few extra dollars a month for.

What Is New Car Replacement Insurance?

If your vehicle is ever damaged beyond repair as a result of a collision, your insurance company will consider it a total loss. In turn, you would be paid out an amount equal to the actual value of your car to be put towards the purchase of a new one.

The problem is, that amount may be a lot less than what you paid for your car when you first bought it, leaving you hundreds or even thousands of dollars in the hole. In many cases, the actual cash value paid out won’t cover the cost to buy a similar car

To solve this problem, you may want to consider taking out a new car replacement insurance policy, which will pay out just enough to cover the cost of a similar vehicle to the one that was totalled. 

New car replacement insurance will compensate you financially if your car is damaged to the point that it isn’t worth repairing. The payout will be sufficient enough to buy another vehicle that’s either the same or a similar make and model, rather than an amount that’s only equal to the depreciated value of the damaged vehicle. 

Without a new car replacement insurance policy, you would have to make up the difference if you want to purchase another car that is the same or very similar to the car that was totalled. 

Once your car has been replaced, your insurance provider may transfer your policy to the new car. Or, the insurer may end the previous policy and require that you take out a new one for the new vehicle

Be sure to go over the fine print in your policy’s contract to verify how your policy will be affected and what steps you need to take to ensure that your new car is adequately insured. 

Are You Eligible For New Car Replacement Insurance?

In order to qualify for new car replacement insurance, you’ll need to meet certain eligibility requirements, including the following:

  • You must be the original registered owner of the car.
  • You may require permission from your lender if you bought the car with a car loan.
  • The vehicle must be under a certain age and mileage limit.
  • The car must be damaged to the point that it is deemed totalled.
  • If the car is stolen, it must be considered a total loss within a certain period of time. 
  • You will need to have collision and comprehensive insurance
  • You may qualify if the car was a registered demo with the dealer.

Is New Car Replacement Insurance The Same As Gap Insurance? 

Gap insurance — which stands for ‘guaranteed auto protection’ or ‘guaranteed asset protection’ — is an optional type of auto insurance that protects you if your car is totalled or stolen. The name is appropriate because this policy essentially bridges the ‘gap’ between the value of your car and the amount you still owe on it. This can be very helpful if you owe more on your car loan than what the vehicle is valued at.

Some people may confuse gap insurance with new car replacement insurance, but they are not the same. New car replacement insurance can help you purchase a similar car to the one that was totalled, while gap insurance is designed to help you pay off the old one. Gap insurance will cover the difference between what you still owe and what the car is worth, less any deductible. 

Pros And Cons Of New Car Replacement Insurance


  • You can get a similar vehicle. With other types of auto insurance, you would be reimbursed for the depreciated value of your current vehicle, which likely won’t be enough to cover the entire cost to replace your car with a similar one. With new car replacement insurance, you can be reimbursed for an amount that will help cover the cost of buying a new car of a similar make and model. 
  • The deductible can be reimbursed. Like any other insurance plan, a deductible is usually required when you file a claim with your new car replacement insurance policy. The good news is that the deductible will be reimbursed by your new car replacement policy. 
  • Your driving record is not taken into consideration. If you have a history of filing many claims, the fact that your driving record won’t be taken into consideration may be beneficial to you. Instead, the premium for this policy is determined based on your car’s value. 


  • Additional cost. Carrying a new car replacement insurance policy will mean paying higher premiums on your insurance plan.
  • Not all features may be covered. Only the accessories included in your original purchase contract will be covered. So, if you decide to have a new navigation system installed in your new car, for instance, you won’t be compensated for it.
  • Limited purchase window. You will only be able to buy a new car replacement insurance policy within a limited time frame, depending on what your insurance provider allows. For example, your insurer may require that this policy be purchased no more than 6 months after you buy a new car. 
  • Your car’s insured value will drop. Once your car exceeds your insurance company’s mileage or age limit, the value of the vehicle will sharply decline. That means your replacement car will not be worth as much as when you initially purchased your new vehicle. 
  • Similar replacements might not be available. In some cases, insurance providers may say that they can’t find a replacement vehicle that’s similar enough to the totalled vehicle. If that happens, you may be forced to find a replacement vehicle on your own. 
  • Certain warranties may not be covered. If you purchased extended warranties on your totalled car when you first bought it, you may not be compensated for what you paid for them.
  • Certain events may not be covered. If your car was destroyed as a result of a flood, fire, or theft, you may not be covered. 

Should You Get New Car Replacement Insurance?

If you recently purchased a new car and are concerned about what type of reimbursement you would receive in the event that it is damaged beyond repair following an accident, then a new car replacement insurance policy may be worth considering. Since vehicles start to depreciate the moment you drive off the dealership’s lot, this type of policy might save you quite a bit of money if you ever have to replace your vehicle at some point. 

New car insurance may be worth it even more if you drive a luxury car since these types of vehicles are more expensive to replace and tend to depreciate faster than the average car. 

Be sure to assess your situation before buying into this policy, as it will cost you a few extra bucks. Also, take into consideration what your insurance company’s requirements are in terms of vehicle age and mileage, as you may not have coverage after a certain point. 

Rating of 5/5 based on 4 votes.

Caitlin is a graduate of Dawson College and Concordia University and has been working in the personal finance industry for over eight years. She believes that education and knowledge are the two most important factors in the creation of healthy financial habits. She also believes that openly discussing money and credit, and the responsibilities that come with them can lead to better decisions and a greater sense of financial security. One of the main ways she’s built good financial habits is by budgeting and tracking her spending through the YNAB budgeting app. She also automates her savings so she never forgets to put aside a portion of her income into her TFSA. She believes investing and passive income is key to earning financial freedom. She also uses her Aeroplan TD credit card to collect Aeroplan points so that she can save money when she travels.

Click on the star to rate it!

How useful was this post?

Research & Compare

Canada's Loan Comparison Platform

Largest Lender Network In Canada

Save time and money with Loans Canada. Research and compare lenders before you apply. Share your experiences with Canada's top lenders.

Make Smarter Borrowing Decisions

Whether you have good credit or poor credit, building financial awareness is the best way to save. Find tips, guides and tools to make better financial decisions.

Save With Loans Canada

Special Offers

50 Free Trades Offer

50 Free Trades Offer
Ends August 31st, 2022

Almost $500 in commission-free trades. Code “50TRADESFREE”. Conditions apply.

View Offer
Earn 5% Cash Back With Neo

Earn 5% Cash Back With Neo
No annual fee!

Earn an average 5%¹ cash back at thousands of partners and at least 1%² cashback guaranteed.

View Offer
Build Credit With Refresh

Build Credit With Refresh

Build credit while spending money with the Refresh Financial VISA card.

View Offer
Build Credit For $7/Month

Build Credit For $7/Month

With KOHO’s prepaid card you can build a better credit score for just $7/month.

View Offer
Industry Spotlight

What's happening with Canada's credit industry?

addy ⎯ Making Real Estate Accessible To All Canadians

addy ⎯ Making Real Estate Accessible To All Canadians

Check out our interview with addy; a platform that allows Canadians to invest in different properties across Canada with as little as $1.

Read Post
Find The Best Rate
In Your Region
Best Personal Loan Provider by Greedy Rates

Confidential & risk-free

All consultations and conversations with Loans Canada and its partners are confidential and risk-free. Speak with a trusted specialist today and see how we can help you achieve your financial goals faster. Loans Canada and its partners will never ask you for an upfront fee, deposit or insurance payments on a loan. Loans Canada is not a mortgage broker and does not arrange mortgage loans or any other type of financial service.

When you apply for a Loans Canada service, our website simply refers your request to qualified third party providers who can assist you with your search. Loans Canada may receive compensation from the offers shown on its website.

Only provide your information to trusted sources and be aware of online phishing scams and the risks associated with them, including identity theft and financial loss. Nothing on this website constitutes professional and/or financial advice.

Your data is protected and your connection is encrypted.

Loans Canada Services Are 100% Free. Disclaimer

Keep Track Of Your Credit Score

Subscribe with Credit Verify to monitor your credit rating and get your free credit score.