Get a free, no obligation personal loan quote with rates as low as 6.99%
Get Started You can apply with no effect to your credit score

There’s something about a heritage home that attracts homebuyers. Perhaps it’s the unique traits of these properties that you don’t normally see in more modern homes, or maybe it’s the rich history that they tie us to. 

If you’re planning to buy a heritage home as your primary residence, you’ll need to take out a home insurance policy to protect it, as your lender will likely require it if you’re taking out a mortgage to finance the purchase. 

But home insurance for heritage homes is slightly different from your average home insurance policy, given the historical significance of these properties. 

What Is A Historical Or Heritage Property? 

A heritage home is a property of significance in the community and possesses physical, historical, and cultural value. These properties are typically quite old and have certain characteristics that you wouldn’t see in modern architecture. 

Heritage homes connect today’s world to the past and are therefore important properties that are deemed in need of some level of protection to retain some of their original traits. 

What Features Make A House A ‘Historical’ Or ‘Heritage’ Property? 

Municipal governments usually designate heritage properties as having certain heritage interests and features such as the age of the building, the building’s historical significance, the exterior architecture and more. 

Due to these features, there are certain restrictions on how these homes can be updated or renovated. These homes often are not built according to today’s building and safety codes, so any work that would be done to them would have to follow a specific protocol to ensure safety while maintaining the integrity of the property. 

Square One insurance

Do You Need Special Home Insurance For Heritage Or Historic Properties? 

A heritage home requires specialized home insurance because these properties are considered a higher risk to insure compared to more modern homes. The local government will have specific regulations in terms of maintenance or modifications for these homes. 

When you take out a home insurance policy on a heritage home, you must declare its designation as a heritage property. Every insurance provider treats a heritage home a little differently. Some may even refuse to insure these historic homes altogether if they perceive the property to be a liability.

Before your policy takes effect, the insurance company will typically send out an agent to conduct a full inspection of the property. Usually, this step wouldn’t be required for the average home insurance policy. Rather, all that would likely be needed is for you to provide all the pertinent information about your home, including its age, square footage, type, and so forth. 

But when it comes to a heritage home, the brokerage will probably want to see the property in person first before a policy is issued and your premiums are determined.

Where Can I Find A Home Insurance Policy For My Heritage Property? 

There are some of the best home insurance providers in Canada. You may find affordable rates with the following providers: 

Loans Canada (Home) logo
Loans Canada
Across Canada
  • Free online quotes
  • Compare multiple options
MyChoice logo
Across Canada
  • Free online quotes
  • Compare multiple options
Insurely logo
Across Canada (except Quebec)
  • Free online quote
  • Discounts may be available
Insurdinary logo
  • Free online quote
  • Compare multiple options
  • Shop for all your insurance needs in one place
Square One logo
Square One
  • Free online quote
  • Discount for policy bundles
Onlia logo
  • Free online quote
  • Discounts available
Apollo logo
  • Low rates starting at $11 per month
  • Free online quote
  • Student tenant insurance policies available

Why Are Insurance Premiums More Expensive For Heritage Or Historic Properties?

When it comes to insurance, your premiums come down to how much risk the insurance company will be taking on. And since heritage homes are very old and may come with components that are out-of-date and potentially hazardous, these types of properties are more expensive to insure.

Outdated Materials

It’s easier to insure heritage homes that have been updated to some degree and regularly maintained, while homes that are in poor condition will be much more difficult to insure, especially if the electrical and pipes are very outdated. Since these structures tend to come with a higher risk, insurance companies will typically charge higher premiums compared to policies for more modern homes. 

Unique And Difficult To Replace Features

It can also be difficult for insurance companies to ensure a heritage home because of its uniqueness. If the home is ever damaged and needs to be replaced, the insurer would have to replace the property with another structure that is similar to it. 

That means the home would have to be rebuilt as closely as it was before the damage was done. Moreover, when it comes to heritage homes, it can be very expensive and challenging to replace these properties and their components with materials similar to what the homes were made of.

Why Are Heritage Homes More Expensive To Update & Repair? 

  • Plaster mouldings – These components require specialized craftsmanship to replace and cannot be created by just any builder. 
  • Planning approvals and by-laws – There are often more obstacles when it comes to getting the appropriate permits and adhering to by-laws when rebuilding a heritage home. This can make the process more expensive and time-consuming.
  • Claims settlement expenses – Since it’s more likely that rebuilding a heritage home can take a long time, the claim will be open for a longer period, which is more costly for an insurance company.
  • Appraiser expertise – Insurance companies will have to pay specialized appraisers who are qualified and experienced in appraising heritage homes.
  • Hazardous components – Materials like asbestos were commonly used in home construction decades ago. As such, the odds of finding asbestos or other dangerous contaminants in a heritage home are more likely. If there is asbestos found in the home, there will be an added cost to safely dispose of it.

Tips When Getting Home Insurance For Heritage Or Historic Properties

Since getting a home insurance policy for a heritage home can be more difficult and expensive, you’ll want to follow certain tips to ensure a comprehensive and cost-effective policy when purchasing these types of historical properties. Consider the following:

Choose The Right Type Of Coverage

In some cases, it might make sense to skip certain types of coverage that may not be necessary and would make the policy more expensive. But when it comes to heritage properties, you don’t want to have a policy that’s too skimpy on coverage. Certain add-ons may be worth adding to your policy to ensure adequate coverage, such as sewer backup for homes with old plumbing. 

The policy should also closely match the home’s value and promise an adequate replacement cost value. You’ll also want to ensure that the property meets the heritage home regulations in your area.

Check out how gender can affect your car insurance premiums.

Comparison Shop

Like any other type of insurance policy, it’s always a good idea to take the time to shop around with different insurance providers to find the best rate without sacrificing coverage. To make this easier for you, enlist the help of an insurance broker who will do all the comparison shopping on your behalf to compare rates and find the best price on a heritage home insurance policy. 

Keep Records

When you buy a heritage home, make sure to retain copies of any documents that come with the home when the deal closes. For example, the property’s legal designation. Store them safely so that they will be readily available if the home is ever damaged and you need to file a claim. 

Find out if you should get hurricane insurance.

Mitigate Risks

There are certain steps you can take to lower the risk of damage to the property and even to reduce the price you pay on premiums. Things such as updating the electrical wiring and plumbing pipes can go a long way in making the home safer while helping to reduce the costs associated with insuring it. 

Make Note Of Unique Features

Heritage homes feature unique characteristics, such as plaster moulding, antique chandeliers, and hand-carved wood finishes. Make sure to document these unique traits with photos and notes. If you have to file a claim, the insurance company will have more to go on when assessing the replacement cost of the home.

Final Thoughts

All homes should be covered with a home insurance policy, and if the home is mortgaged, the lender will require insurance coverage. However, an insurance policy may be even more important for a heritage home given its potentially increased value and higher costs to replace components that may be difficult to replicate. Just be sure to do your homework and shop around for a policy that provides you with adequate coverage at a price point you can afford. 

Heritage Homes FAQs

What is a heritage house?

Properties with historical or cultural significance are considered a ‘heritage’ or ‘historical’ property. These properties are generally designated as such by the municipal government and have certain restrictions on how they can be renovated or updated.

Can I renovate my heritage house?

Yes, you can renovate your heritage house, however, there may be certain restrictions on how or what you can renovate. In fact, in certain provinces, like Alberta, you’ll need to gain permission from the Provincial Heritage Permit before making any changes. This is to ensure that any renovations made are keeping with the history of the property.

Is heritage home insurance more expensive?

Yes, generally heritage home insurance is more expensive than regular home insurance because they have more restrictions on how it can be repaired. Moreover, heritage homes often have special features that require specialized craftsmanship to repair. Furthermore, heritage homes are constructed with materials that are outdated, which can increase the risk of fire and other damages.
Caitlin Wood, BA avatar on Loans Canada
Caitlin Wood, BA

Caitlin Wood is the Editor-in-Chief at Loans Canada and specializes in personal finance. She is a graduate of Dawson College and Concordia University and has been working in the personal finance industry for over eight years. Caitlin has covered various subjects such as debt, credit, and loans. Her work has been published on Zoocasa, GoDaddy, and deBanked. She believes that education and knowledge are the two most important factors in the creation of healthy financial habits. She also believes that openly discussing money and credit, and the responsibilities that come with them can lead to better decisions and a greater sense of financial security.

More From This Author

Special Offers

More From Our Experts
Loans Canada places No. 228 on The Globe and Mail’s fifth-annual ranking of Canada’s Top Growing Companies.

By Caitlin Wood, BA
Published on September 29, 2023

Loans Canada is excited to announce it has made it onto the Globe and Mail’s Top Growing Companies list for the second year in a row.
Finder Awards Finalists: Personal Loans Customer Satisfaction Awards 2023

By Priyanka Correia, BComm

Loans Canada is happy to announce it received the finalist award in the Best Personal Loan Search Platform category.
Beware of Fraudulent Lenders Impersonating Loans Canada

By Caitlin Wood, BA

A note to our clients about fraudulent lending practices and illegal upfront fees.
Do You Qualify For Disability Assistance In BC?

By Matthew Taylor

The BC Disability Assistance Program provides monthly disability assistance payments to people with the Persons with Disabilities (PWD) Designation.
High Ratio Mortgages And Default Mortgage Insurance

By Sandra MacGregor

Are you putting less than 20% on your home? Then you'll have a high-ratio mortgage. Find out how that'll affect the amount of default insurance you'll...
How Do Foreclosures Work In Canada?

By Lisa Rennie

Missed mortgage payments can result in foreclosure, which can leave you without your home. Learn more about how foreclosures work in Canada.
How To Avoid CMHC Fees In Canada

By Lisa Rennie

Want to avoid paying CMHC fees? We have the tips and tricks you need on to avoid paying CMHC fees in Canada.
2024 Federal Budget: Making Homeownership More Achievable

By Sean Cooper

Check out the Federal Budget 2024 initiatives made to make housing more affordable and accessible in Canada.

Recognized As One Of Canada's Top Growing Companies

Loans Canada, the country's original loan comparison platform, is proud to be recognized as one of Canada's fastest growing companies by The Globe and Mail!

Read More

Why choose Loans Canada?

Apply Once &
Get Multiple Offers
Save Time
And Money
Get Your Free
Credit Score
Expert Tips
And Advice

Build Credit For Just $10/Month

With KOHO's prepaid card you can build a better credit score for just $10/month.

Koho Prepaid Credit Card