When Do I Choose A Personal Loan Over Using My Credit Card?

Fairstone
Author:
Fairstone
Fairstone
Expert Contributor at Loans Canada
Caitlin
Reviewed By:
Caitlin
Caitlin Wood, BA
Editor-in-Chief at Loans Canada
Caitlin Wood has more than a decade of experience helping Canadian consumers learn how to take control of their finances. Expertise:
  • Personal finance
  • Consumer borrowing
  • Credit improvement
  • Debt management
📅
Updated On: June 5, 2024
iCash

Ad Disclosure

Approval is not guaranteed and conditions apply.

British Columbia Residents: iCash offers payday loans in British Columbia (license number: 67639)

Ontario Residents: Loan amounts and repayment terms are subject to qualification requirements. The maximum allowable cost of borrowing under the payday loan agreement is $14 for every $100 advanced. On a $500 loan of 14 days, the total cost of borrowing is $70, with a total payback amount of $570 and an APR of 365%. On a loan of 62 days, the APR is 82.42%.

Manitoba Residents: To learn more about your rights as a payday loan borrower, contact the Consumer Protection Office at 1-204-945-3800 or 1-800-782-0067 or at www.manitoba.ca/cca/cpo

Nova Scotia Residents: Payday loans are High Cost Loans. The maximum allowable cost of borrowing under the payday loan agreement is 14$ per every 100$ received, which means on a 100$ loan for 14 days, the total cost of borrowing is 14$, with total payback amount of 114$ and an APR of 365.00%.

PEI Residents: Loan amounts and repayment terms are subject to qualification requirements. The maximum allowable cost of borrowing under the payday loan agreement is $14 for every $100 advanced. On a $300 loan of 14 days, the total cost of borrowing is $42, with a total payback amount of $342 and an APR of 365.00%. On a loan of 62 days, the APR is 82.42%.

The Cashback Program and Refer a Friend Program are not available in Manitoba, British Columbia and New Brunswick.

Get a free, no obligation personal loan quote with rates as low as 9.99%
Free quote with no impact to your credit

For this post, we’ve teamed up with our partners at Fairstone

When you need to borrow money to cover an unexpected expense (even if ‘borrowing’ is just on your credit card), you want to consider your borrowing options. Since you probably have a credit card on-hand, it’s easy to make that your quick decision. But when is a credit card not the right choice?  

We asked our friends at Fairstone to investigate a few situations when you might find it more valuable to make payments with a loan rather than your credit card. Here’s what they found:

4 situations when a personal loan makes more sense than a credit card

1) The Payment is Substantial

It’s one thing to use your credit card for minor purchases, which can easily be paid off at your next billing cycle, but it’s another thing altogether if you’re putting hundreds or even thousands of dollars on your credit card. Unless you have the cash on hand to pay off big purchases immediately, leaving a large amount of debt on your credit card can send you into a cycle of unpaid balances. 

An unpaid credit card balance can damage your credit over time. Some people may argue that everything will be fine as long as you’re making minimum payments, but, the longer you let this go on for, the more interest charges will build. 

Not sure why that’s an issue? Read this article on the impact of credit card interest (compound interest) on an unpaid balance.  

2) You’re Already Dealing With Credit Card Debt

On a similar topic, if your credit card balance is already greater than 25% of your credit limit, you’ll want to avoid putting any more debt on there. Having a credit card balance that is greater than 25% of your available credit can have a negative impact on your credit score (whereas balances under 25% can help your credit score). Interested in credit utilization? Click here

3) Come To Think Of It, You’d Like To Get Rid Of Your Credit Card Debt Anyway

On top of providing the funds for a purchase, you can use a personal loan to consolidate and pay off outstanding debts. If you have multiple credit cards or loans with various balances, payment amounts and repayment dates, you may want to consider debt consolidation. Not only will you get the up-front cash you need to make a purchase, but your other debts will be paid off and you’ll have a simplified debt repayment plan – one loan, one payment amount and a payment frequency that works for you. Learn how you can pay off bills faster with a debt consolidation loan.

Another benefit of a personal loan? They are a form of installment debt. Unlike a credit card (which is a type of revolving debt), installment loans have a set repayment term and a set borrowing amount, meaning you know when you’ll be debt-free and exactly how much you’ll be paying back. For comparison, look at your next credit card bill – it should tell you how long it will take to pay off your current balance if you only make minimum payments. Typically, this number is a lot longer than a repayment term on a personal loan. 

4) You Can Get A Better Interest Rate With A Loan

Before putting an expense on your credit card, if you know you’ll be carrying the debt for more than one billing cycle you’ll want to consider interest rates. If you’ve already missed a few payments, the rate on your credit card may have spiked. Unfortunately, a lot of people overlook this subtlety in their credit card agreement. You could get a better rate by opting for a personal loan, especially if you’re a homeowner. 

Want to how much a personal loan may cost you? Visit Fairstone’s no-obligation loan quote to find out how much money you could qualify for, and what your payments might be. If you’re a homeowner, let the Lending Specialist know, and they can offer you a personalized quote for a secured personal loan. 

In Conclusion

A credit card is helpful when you are making all your payments and not carrying outstanding debt, but if you’ve found it tough to fully pay off large credit card balances in the past, it may not be the best financial decision for you. It can be a good option to choose a personal loan when you need money but you don’t want to keep using it for debt again and again; instead, you can focus on repaying the debt, helping to empower yourself as a borrower.

Remember, when you’re thinking about a personal loan or a credit card, consider:

  • The size of the debt
  • The current state of your credit card balance
  • Whether you may want to consolidate debt anyway
  • The interest rate you’re likely to receive
Fairstone avatar on Loans Canada
Fairstone

Fairstone Financial is a leading alternative lender in Canada, they have been helping Canadians since 1923. Their mission is to provide Canadians, with fair to good credit, with an affordable alternative to payday loans.

More From This Author

Special Offers

More From Our Experts

https://loanscanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Personal-Reference-Loan.png
Do You Need A Personal Reference For A Loan?

By Lisa Rennie
Updated on September 11, 2025

Whether it’s an employer or lender. There are many occasions when your character will be put to the test through a personal reference request.

https://loanscanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/Instant-loan-approval.png
Instant Loan With Bad Credit: What You Need To Know

By Lisa Rennie
Updated on September 10, 2025

The guarantee of instant loan approval is appealing, but not always possible. Let's take a look at how to get approved with bad credit.

https://loanscanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/Loan-Guarantor-1.png
Who Can Be A Guarantor For A Loan?

By Lisa Rennie
Updated on September 10, 2025

Thinking about being a loan guarantor? Do you know what the requirements are and what is expected of you? Read this article to find out.

https://loanscanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/ODSP-Loan.png
How To Get A Loan On ODSP?

By Caitlin Wood, BA
Updated on September 4, 2025

Explore your options for getting a loan while on ODSP. Learn about the requirements and tips to secure financing without affecting your benefits.

https://loanscanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Payday-loan-apps.png
Best Payday Loan Apps In Canada

By Caitlin Wood, BA
Updated on September 2, 2025

Compare the top payday loan apps in Canada for easy application, minimal paperwork, and fast approvals and funding.

https://loanscanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/bad-credit-student-loans.png
Guide: Getting Student Loans With Bad Credit

By Caitlin Wood, BA
Updated on August 29, 2025

Are you looking into getting student loans with bad credit to help cover the cost of your education? Here are some of the options available.

https://loanscanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Government-funding-for-az-license-ontario.png
Can You Get Government Funding For An AZ License In Ontario?

By Lisa Rennie
Updated on August 28, 2025

An AZ license in Ontario is expensive. Find out if you can get government funding for an AZ license in Ontario.

https://loanscanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/MBA-program-in-Canada.png
How To Finance An MBA Program In Canada

By Lisa Rennie
Updated on August 25, 2025

MBA programs in Canada are expensive. Find out how you can finance your MBA in Canada and enhance your career options.

Recognized As One Of Canada's Top Growing Companies

Why choose Loans Canada?

Apply Once &
Get Multiple Offers
Save Time
And Money
Get Your Free
Credit Score
Free
Service
Expert Tips
And Advice
Exclusive
Offers